The Perfumer’s Secret by Fiona McIntosh

I’d been wanting to read one of Fiona McIntosh’s historical fiction novels for such a long time, and I finally got around to it! I listened to the audiobook of this, and I have to say:

This was pretty hilariously bad.

Entertaining, sure. And McIntosh has also certainly done her research on the time period; the actual setting was really fun and interesting to read about. But basically, this was just an historical romance novel dressed up to look classier. Now, don’t get me wrong, I love a good historical romance. I’ve read quite a lot! But when I go into a book having certain expectations, it can be really confusing and really put me off if things are different than expected. I mean, really, look at some of McIntosh’s covers:

mcintosh

These are pretty indicative of most of her Australian covers. These say to me “Here’s an historical fiction novel, that deals with hard topics (war etc.), but isn’t too heavy, and there will probably be some romance in there somewhere to liven things up”.

The major issue I had with this book was not only that the romance took up most of the book (when there were many other interesting things we could have focused on), but also the romance itself was very off-putting. Fleurette constantly compares her love interest to her brothers. I mean, constantly. It’s weird and gross. Sure, she can admire similar qualities in Sebastian that she admires in her two brothers, but she often refers to how similar Sebastian looks to her twin brother. And there is some major insta-love going on. There was one point in the novel where I had actually forgotten how much time was supposed to have passed between Sebastian and Fleurette having met. Luckily for me, when Fleurette declares her undying love for Sebastian, she states “I know I only met you yesterday, but I love you!”. Yesterday. It’s only been a day since the MET. I laughed out loud when I read this part. Sebastian himself is ok, nothing to write home about. Of course, he’s “bedded many women” and is skilled in the art of seduction, and our main character is a virgin. Because that is definitely not a trope I’m sick of.

Aimery was comically evil. Yes, we are to understand that he is not a good guy: but things get pretty ridiculous. I will say this though, I’d never heard the name Aimery before, and now I love it, so there’s something.

Fleurette is portrayed throughout the novel as being a strong-willed young women, willing to push social boundaries so as not to live her life as the oppressed wife of a wealthy and respected man. This was pushed onto the reader so much, so often that it didn’t work at all. Too much telling, not enough showing. The novel opens with Fleurette being forced to wed Aimery against all her wishes. Giving in so willingly to this goes against her whole character, it actually makes no sense.

The thing I enjoyed the most about this novel was the setting: Grasse, in Southern France. I had never heard of Grasse and really enjoyed learning about the town that is considered the perfume capital of the world. The descriptions for the setting were truly lovely.

Grasse

Grasse

This definitely wasn’t a great book, but I found it entertaining enough. Mostly because it was quite ridiculous. I’m definitely willing to give McIntosh another go, probably again on Audiobook, as the narrator of this, Madeleine Leslay, was quite nice to listen to. And I got to learn about Grasse, which was fun.

2 Comments

  1. November 9, 2016 / 6:12 PM

    I would love to read this kind of story,so much entertaining tho.

    • November 10, 2016 / 10:37 AM

      It was definitely entertaining, I’ll give it that!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: